Harmonies and Controversy: Prestwich Children’s Carol Service Sparks Debate Amid Festive Joy

In a quaint corner of Prestwich, the sounds of joy and celebration took center stage as children from St Mary’s CE Primary School performed at a much-loved carol service. Held at the Rectory Green complex near the village center, the event was a festive blend of carols, Christmas songs, and lively dances that brought smiles to attendees. Yet, beneath the twinkling lights and merry tunes, a surprising controversy has stirred.

The annual event, organized by the Prestwich and North Western Housing Association, faced criticism after a complaint was lodged, claiming the service “promoted Christianity” and was inappropriate for a community gathering.

Mike Corfield, CEO of the housing association, described the carol service as “a delight” that was warmly received by the many tenants and parents who attended. Speaking to The Bury Times, Corfield said, “Supporting the carol singing is an important part of building community spirit and bringing joy during the festive season.”

However, the association’s December newsletter acknowledged the complaint, with Corfield emphasizing that no offense was intended. He further reassured residents that their views are valued, adding that a survey has been launched to gauge feedback.

So far, the results appear overwhelmingly positive—40 tenants, representing 20% of Rectory Court residents, have responded, all voicing their support for the event.

A Community Tradition

The carol service, now in its second year, originated from a local community member’s idea and has become a budding tradition. The collaboration with St Mary’s CE Primary School not only showcased the children’s talents but also engaged residents in decorating the venue and fostering a sense of unity.

Corfield praised the efforts of the school’s children and teachers, saying, “The event was attended by many tenants and some parents of the children. It was a delightful evening, with carols, Christmas songs, and entertaining dances.”

Balancing Celebration and Inclusion

While the festive spirit was palpable, the complaint has reignited debates about inclusivity in public spaces. The association has reassured tenants that all feedback is taken seriously, adhering to the housing ombudsman’s complaints handling code.

Corfield remarked, “We want to ensure we are providing a service that residents support, and the views of our tenants are the most important.”

The survey’s full results are set to be published in the new year, offering a clearer picture of how the community feels about the event’s religious undertones.

Bridging Differences During the Festive Season

As the debate unfolds, the service’s charm and the children’s performances have left an indelible mark on attendees. For many, the event was more than just a celebration of Christmas—it was a reminder of the power of community, tradition, and shared joy.

Whether the carol service continues next year remains to be seen, but for now, the children of St Mary’s CE Primary School have gifted their community something truly special: a night of music, laughter, and festive cheer, resonating long after the last note faded.