The Pews in Silence: Uncovering the Decline of Biblical Church Discipline

A recent survey by Lifeway Research has shed light on a concerning trend in modern Protestant churches: the decline of biblical church discipline. Despite biblical commands and Jesus’ example, many churches are avoiding discipline altogether. According to the survey, only one in six pastors reported that their church had disciplined a member in the previous 12 months. Over half of pastors stated that their congregations had never formally reprimanded a member during their tenure.

A Culture of Silence

The survey’s findings suggest that the infrequency of church discipline is not due to a lack of sin among church members, but rather a lack of willingness to address it. Scott McConnell, executive director of Lifeway Research, noted that church discipline typically occurs when a member is unrepentant or no longer qualified for a role due to sin. The survey also revealed that larger churches are more likely to encounter situations warranting discipline, and that teachings and traditions play a significant role in a church’s willingness to discipline [2].

A Call to Return to Biblical Principles

The decline of biblical church discipline is a complex issue, influenced by various factors, including denominational differences and a lack of formal policies. While 80% of churches have official discipline procedures, they are rarely enforced. As the church navigates the challenges of the modern world, it must return to biblical principles and prioritize discipline as a means of promoting spiritual growth and accountability.