COLBERT STUNS FAITHFUL: Late-Night Host Backs Female Jesus as ‘Long Overdue’ in Shocking Hollywood Revival

LOS ANGELES, CA — In a move certain to ignite fierce debate among Christians, late-night icon and professing Roman Catholic Stephen Colbert has openly endorsed a female portrayal of Jesus Christ—calling the controversial casting “long overdue.”

The bombshell remarks came during a recent interview with British actress Cynthia Erivo, who is set to make history as the first woman to play Jesus in a major production of Jesus Christ Superstar at the Hollywood Bowl this August.

“Long Overdue”: Colbert’s Provocative Endorsement

Colbert, known for his sharp wit and Catholic faith, did not mince words when discussing Erivo’s groundbreaking role.

“One of my favorite musicals of all time is ‘Jesus Christ Superstar,'” the Late Show host said. “I love that—and I’m so excited that in August, you’re going to be playing Jesus… First woman to play Jesus in a major production. Long overdue. I’ve said for years I’d love to see a woman in that part.”

The statement marks a stark departure from traditional Christian depictions of Christ, raising eyebrows among conservative Catholics and evangelicals alike.

Erivo’s Historic Role: “A Very Special Thing”

Erivo, an openly bisexual actress and singer, acknowledged the significance of the milestone. When asked by Colbert what the role meant to her, she called it “a very special thing.”

The casting has already drawn mixed reactions, with progressives hailing it as a bold step toward inclusivity while traditionalists condemn it as sacrilegious.

Theological Firestorm Erupts

Colbert’s remarks have thrust the upcoming production into the center of a cultural and religious firestorm.

• Traditionalist Outrage: Prominent Catholic leaders have condemned the portrayal, with theologian Dr. Robert Barron calling it “a deliberate distortion of sacred truth.”

• Progressive Praise: Meanwhile, LGBTQ+ advocates and liberal faith leaders applaud the move as “a powerful reimagining of divine representation.”

Colbert’s Catholic Contradiction?

As a public Catholic, Colbert has often discussed his faith on air—making his endorsement of a female Jesus all the more shocking. Critics argue that his stance clashes with Church teaching, while supporters insist artistic reinterpretation does not equate to doctrinal defiance.

What’s Next?

With the Hollywood Bowl performances just weeks away, the debate is sure to intensify. Will this reimagining of Christ spark a broader conversation about gender and faith—or deepen the divide between tradition and progressive revision?

One thing is certain: Stephen Colbert just turned Jesus Christ Superstar into the most controversial show of the year.